Trump's Briefing Fiasco
And why the TV networks should stop airing them live and unchecked.
|Scott Nover||Mar 24||1|
I’m Scott Nover. Welcome back to Pressing, a newsletter about press freedom. If you haven’t yet subscribed, you can do so here and receive this letter in your inbox every Tuesday morning as well as special features for paid subscribers.
This is the 36th issue of Pressing and it’s great to have you with me. Please send me feedback, thoughts, suggestions, and tips at email@example.com.
Why Cable Networks Should Think Twice before They Air Trump’s Task Force Briefings Live
For the last two weeks—or what has felt like an eternity—President Donald Trump and his White House Coronavirus Task Force have given regular, if not daily “briefings” about the state of the government’s response. These sessions have gotten significantly worse in recent days.
We’ve seen more of Trump and less of National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases director Anthony Fauci, a.k.a. the only adult in the room. Beyond that, these sessions have been at best unhelpful and at worst dangerous.
Saint Thomas Chloroquinas
Trump has repeatedly pushed unproven medical advice about hydroxychloroquine, a family of old antimalarial drugs, as a potential treatment for COVID-19. While there have been opinion pieces in The Wall Street Journal and commentary on Fox News supporting Trump’s hypothesis, this is not currently an FDA-approved treatment for COVID-19. Because of Trump’s crazy talk, there is a shortage of these important drugs which people actually need for diseases and disorders like lupus or rheumatoid arthritis. And there have been directly dire consequences too. Three people in Nigeria have been admitted to a hospital for chloroquine poisoning and, in Arizona, a man has died after ingesting chloroquine phosphate, a parasite treatment for fish. His wife is currently hospitalized for doing the same and said the couple took the chloroquine phosphate after hearing Trump talk about the effects of the medication form of chloroquine.
A Bully of the Press
Trump has consistently bashed journalists throughout this process. On March 13, Trump insulted PBS NewsHour correspondent Yamiche Alcindor, saying she asked a “nasty question” for inquiring whether he takes responsibility for disbanding the National Security Council’s pandemic office. On Friday, Trump completely unloaded on NBC News correspondent Peter Alexander after Alexander asked whether Trump was touting unproven drugs and giving people false hope. “What do you say to Americans who are scared?” Alexander asked during the exchange. “I say that you are a terrible reporter,” Trump replied. “That's what I say.” He continuing by insulting Alexander, NBC, and its parent company Comcast. On Monday, he called reporters “angry, angry people.” And his Twitter feed has been a hotbed of anti-press tweets.
Cable Networks Need to Stop Going Live to the Briefing
We’re living through trying times and there’s so much at stake. Every day, Americans are dying and many more are getting sick from the coronavirus. We want to hear from our political leaders. Some politicians, including some governors like New York’s Andrew Cuomo, have been giving helpful, realistic, rational, and even comforting briefings. This is not what Trump has been doing. He’s been peddling misinformation, attacking reporters, joking about the disease, joking about the deep state, using racist dogwhistles like calling the coronavirus the Chinese virus, bragging that he’s a “wartime president,” and insulting his political enemies like Senator Mitt Romney who is in quarantine. Above all, Trump is confusing the American people.
We are dealing with an unprecedented global crisis and we, as Americans, have a leadership vacuum. Our president is too narcissistic, too uncouth, too callous to care what’s accurate and what’s not, what’s appropriate and what’s not, what’s helpful and what’s dangerous.
I’m not the only person to make this argument. Smart thinkers like The Washington Post’s Margaret Sullivan and The Atlantic’s James Fallows have voiced similar opinions. Here’s what I believe: It’s frankly irresponsible for television networks to air unedited, unchecked statements from the president because his words have an immediate and negative effect on the country’s preparedness for this crisis. The news media is doing the public, its audience, a disservice when it shows Trump live and unchecked.
Trump is a performer. Cut the live feeds and maybe he’ll cut some of the crap. Either way, he cannot be trusted at a time of national crisis: He’s proven that time and again. It’s time to figure out whose words may save lives, and whose words may cost lives.
Do you love Pressing and want to support it? If you are able and interested, please consider a paid subscription here! I produce this letter on my own dime and in my own time.
New RCFP Recommendations
The Reporters Committee published recommendations for journalists, legislators and courts to “ensure access to government information and proceedings is protected” during the coronavirus response effort. The resources focus on access to open meetings and public records, newsgathering in a time of social distancing and shelter in place policies, and judicial transparency. You can read the announcement here and access the recommendations here.
What Else is New?
I strongly recommend Ben Smith’s latest New York Times column: Rupert Murdoch Put His Son in Charge of Fox. It Was a Dangerous Mistake.
With such an influx of news every week, I’m really looking toward the Sunday morning talk shows as an important re-setting point before each week. That’s NBC’s Meet the Press, FOX’s Fox News Sunday, ABC’s This Week, CBS’s Face the Nation, and CNN’s State of the Union. In 2018, I wrote a feature in The Atlantic making the case for why they’re essential viewing during the Trump era. You can read it here.
Last Tuesday, China announced it would expel American journalists working for The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal, and The Washington Post while ordering that Voice of America and Time give the government additional information about their operations. The editors of all three newspapers signed an open letter to the Chinese government asking them to reverse the decision. The letter will appear as a full-page ad in each print newspaper Tuesday, and will be published on each paper’s website.
Ads for medical face masks are slipping through the cracks and appearing on major publishers’ websites, CNN reports.
Poynter’s Kelly McBride and Rick Edmonds ask “Do news sites have an ethical duty to remove paywalls on coronavirus coverage?”
The White House Correspondents Association has cancelled its annual dinner, originally scheduled for April 25.